Fall has descended, which means it’s officially sweater season—a time to elevate your wardrobe with cozy, timeless knits and retire those tired, worn-out pieces. Here’s your definitive guide to the sweaters you need to invest in and those that have outlived their welcome.
1. Buy: Chunky Cable-Knit Sweaters
A chunky cable-knit sweater is a must-have for any fall wardrobe. These textured beauties add depth to your outfit and provide warmth without sacrificing style. Look for rich hues like deep burgundy, forest green, or classic cream. Pair them with high-waisted jeans or leather leggings for a modern take on a cozy classic—layer with a tailored coat and ankle boots for a polished, autumnal look.
2. Bin: Pilled and Faded Sweaters
No matter how beloved sweaters that have seen better days—marked by pilling, faded fabric, or a stretched-out fit—need to go. They detract from your overall look and make even the most carefully curated outfit appear careless. Replace them with fresh, high-quality pieces that look and feel luxurious.
3. Buy: Oversized Turtleneck Sweaters
An oversized turtleneck is the epitome of effortless chic. Opt for neutral tones like soft beige, charcoal, or warm taupe for versatility, and wear them with sleek trousers or a pencil skirt to balance out the volume. Add statement earrings for a dash of elegance, or wear them casually with straight-leg jeans and loafers for a laid-back, sophisticated vibe.
4. Bin: Itchy Fabrics
Life is too short for uncomfortable sweaters. If it itches or irritates your skin, it’s time to part ways. Opt for materials like cashmere, merino wool, or cotton blends that feel as good as they look. Sweaters should be a pleasure to wear, not a chore.
5. Buy: Classic Cashmere Sweaters
Cashmere is synonymous with luxury, and a well-made cashmere sweater is a timeless investment piece. Choose versatile shades like navy, camel, or blush, which can easily transition from work to weekend. Pair with tailored trousers for the office or layer under a blazer for a smart, elevated look.
6. Bin: Outdated Patterns
Bold, outdated patterns can make your sweater collection feel stuck in a time warp. If you’re still holding on to oversized geometric prints or quirky holiday-themed sweaters, it’s time to let them go. Instead, embrace refined designs like subtle stripes, herringbone, or monochromatic looks that exude modern elegance.
7. Buy: Cropped Sweaters
Cropped sweaters are having a moment this season and are ideal for layering. Look for soft knits in autumnal shades like burnt orange, olive, or mustard, and pair them with high-waisted skirts or trousers. For an edgy twist, layer over a crisp button-up or a slip dress for a contemporary and chic look.
8. Bin: Stretched-Out Necks
A sagging neckline not only looks unflattering but also feels sloppy. Whether it’s a once-loved V-neck or a stretched-out crewneck, if the shape has lost its integrity, it’s time to replace it. Opt for well-constructed knits that hold their form and give your look a clean, put-together appearance.
9. Buy: Sweater Dresses
Sweater dresses are the ultimate in cozy-meets-sophisticated attire. Look for designs that flatter your figure, such as belted or fitted silhouettes in colors like wine, charcoal, or rich chocolate. Pair with knee-high boots and a tailored coat for an effortlessly chic fall outfit that transitions seamlessly from day to night.
10. Bin: Baggy, Shapeless Sweaters
There’s a fine line between oversized and shapeless. If a sweater has lost all definition and hangs on you like a blanket, it’s time to let it go. Invest in pieces that drape well but still maintain a flattering structure. Look for high-quality fabrics that keep their shape wear after wear.
11. Buy: Statement Sleeve Sweaters
This season, it’s all about the sleeve. Puffed, bell, or balloon sleeves add a touch of drama to your knitwear collection. Choose muted tones like soft gray or cream to let the silhouette shine. Pair with slim trousers or a fitted skirt to create a balanced, fashion-forward look.
12. Bin: Too-Thin Sweaters
If your sweater is so thin that it offers little warmth or can’t be layered effectively, it’s probably not worth keeping. Seek out medium-weight knits in luxurious fabrics like wool blends or cashmere that will withstand the season’s chill while maintaining a refined aesthetic.
13. Buy: Neutral Cardigans
A neutral cardigan is a layering essential that belongs in every wardrobe. Stick to timeless colors like oatmeal, slate, or black for maximum versatility. Whether draping it over a crisp white shirt or pairing it with a slip dress, a well-fitted cardigan adds an extra layer of warmth without compromising style.
14. Bin: Anything with Stains You Can’t Remove
Even your most cherished sweater isn’t worth keeping if permanent stains mar it. Whether it’s coffee spills or moth holes, if the damage is beyond repair, it’s time to let it go. Replace it with a fresh knit that makes you feel polished and put together.
15. Buy: Colorblock Sweaters
Colorblock sweaters add a modern, playful touch to your fall wardrobe. Opt for elegant color combinations like navy, cream, or soft pink with taupe. Pair them with dark denim or tailored slacks to strike the perfect balance between casual and sophisticated.